- Media Centre
Monday 10th August 2015
Businesses disputing the meaning of clauses in commercial contracts may find the courts uphold the terms, even if they are commercially disastrous, following a Supreme Court decision.
Under leases entered into by tenants of chalets in a caravan park, the tenants had to pay a fixed service charge of £90 for the first year of the term, increasing by 10% every year on a compound basis. This meant that service charges for 2015 for a lease granted in 1980 were over £2,500, and would rise to around £550,000 by the end of the lease.
The tenants argued that this was such an uncommercial outcome it could not have been intended by the parties when they entered into the lease. There have been recent legal rulings in which the courts have interpreted the intentions of parties to a contract on the basis of whether the contract terms are commercially sensible, irrespective of the clear words used.
In this case, the Supreme Court resurrected the previous approach taken by the courts. It ruled that clear, unambiguous words in a contract should not be overturned merely because they are not commercially sensible – even if the outcome is commercially disastrous. It confirmed the following principles to be applied:
These principles clarify that the courts will give words in a commercial contract their natural meaning, whether commercially sensible or not. Only if the words are ambiguous will they then look to commercial common sense to determine what the parties intended them to mean.
In this case, the court said the meaning of the service charge clauses had to be assessed in the light of:
Subjective evidence of either party’s intentions should be disregarded.
On this basis, given the clear words in the leases, the Supreme Court ruled in favour of the landlord.
Case ref: Arnold v Britton & Ors  UKSC 36
ã Atom Content Marketing 2015
Author: Peter Hine
See more news from 2015.
RIchard Ainsworth is professional and responsive. FIrst class solicitor! - Paula Goulding
Marsden Rawsthorn Solicitors Ltd trading as Marsden Rawsthorn | T&Cs | Sitemap | firstname.lastname@example.org
Reg. Address Faraday Court, Faraday Drive, Fulwood Preston, PR2 9NB | VAT Number 154 1096 28
Authorised and Regulated by The Solicitors Regulation Authority. Authority number 591294.
For details of the professional rules governing the conduct of solicitors go to www.sra.org.uk/code-of-conduct.page
Powered by Thule Media.