Case law: Employers dismissing employees following a 'breakdown in relations' between them should first ensure they cannot work together

Friday 12th August 2016

Employers planning to dismiss an employee because of a 'breakdown in relations' between them should consider giving the employee a chance to prove in practice that they can to work harmoniously before dismissing them.


An employee was dismissed on grounds that the relationship between her and her employer had broken down irretrievably. Her employer argued that this meant she was dismissed for 'some other substantial reason' and her dismissal was therefore fair.  She claimed that the relationship had not irretrievably broken down and suggested ways in which she could continue to work with her colleagues.


The Employment Appeal Tribunal (EAT) agreed that an objective reasonable employer would not have concluded that the employment relationship was beyond repair to the extent that dismissal was a reasonable option.


Particularly, the EAT found that she had not been given the chance to show that she could work harmoniously with her colleagues. Notably, it also found that the ACAS Code of Practice on Disciplinary and Grievance Procedures did not apply to dismissals for 'some other substantial reason' following a breakdown in working relationships.


Operative date

  • Now



  • Employers planning to dismiss an employee because of an alleged breakdown in relations between employer and employee should consider whether to give the employee a chance to prove, in practice, that they can continue to work harmoniously with their colleagues


Case ref: Phoenix House Ltd v Stockman & Anor UKEAT/0264/15/DM


 Atom Content Marketing 2016

Author: Lisa Clark

Don't Miss

  • Walk the Lights for Rosemere - Posted by A-1 on 2017-10-19
  • 10% off LPA when you do a Will at the same time - Posted by A-1 on 2017-10-13
  • Get To Know Our New Starters - Posted by A-1 on 2017-08-29
  • Supporting Rosemere with staff Christmas Jumper Day - Posted by A-1 on 2017-12-15
    • It is always a great pleasure to meet with Eric Gardner - such a lovely man and so professional and thorough!